TITLE = The Miracle of Castel di Sangro AUTHOR = Joe McGinniss PRICE = US $25 list, $17.50 discount (hardback) SIZE = YEAR = 1999 SOURCE = book stores, online RATING = 3 stars
A somewhat contraversial book, almost one that you either love or hate.
The story line is basically an American author travels to Italy to follow
around the Serie B club Castel di Sangro. It certainly has the makings of
superb work. It has all the ingedients: desperate relegation struggle, a
small isolated town, the local mafia don that owns the club, etc.
The main criticism that most readers will express is that the author
eventually comes off as a total jerk. Aside from the obvious ludicrous
situation of him trying to "advise" the coach on how the game would be
played, he also ends up viciously criticizing everything and everybody,
and
adds unnecessary personal insults. (Just imagine some Italian journalist
coming over here and telling Billy Martin how to run his baseball team...)
At times, you wonder what planet McGinness comes from, as he exhibits a
certain degree of, err, naivite. Castel di Sangro throws a game. He's
outraged, to the point of being ridiculous. What, corruption in Serie B?
Gee, what a novel concept! Who'da thunk it?
What ultimately saves the book is the topic itself: the wonderful story of
Castel di Sangro and their struggle in the Serie B. McGinniss was given a
unique insight into the Italian game, with all its faults. Unfortunately
he lets his ego get the way of the story, or perhaps he tried too hard to
make himself the focus. This book should be read, but you might
want to consider borrowing from the local library.