Top / Cal Courses, Announcements / EA105 / Joint Essay Set

 

JES07 & JES07R — PCS 03: writing country-to-country comparison then responding to your partner's PCS

WORKING SEPARATELY BUT EXCHANGING IDEAS

General comments

Review: The previous step introduced the very difficult film-to-film comparison process. This exercise takes this farther and your ICE is the supreme statement on it, although that will be mediated with the final joint statement. Film-to-film comparisons fall quickly into superficial observations if you don't stick to your guns and look deep into the values and worldviews that help create and constraint their narratives.

Note: This step has only two questions to answer (and two to respond to so, in total, four short mini-essays). But these brief statements stand on the the quality of your efforts. So, lots of good thinking, then clear expression of results. This is the most difficult of the three PCSs, and with this PCS we are beginning to move into the zone where I grade from the frame of mind of "Has the student understood the rules, goals and methods of this class well enough to use them effectively?" This will continue to become more important as we move towards the end of the term. The ICE and Midterm 03 are "hottest" on this point but the final joint essay is important as well (it is just that the complicated nature of that assignment limits freedom of expression somewhat).

How to complete the JES07 & JES07R steps

Use the same sending / exchanging process that is described in JES05 & JES05R.

Here is the Form-JES07.

 

>>>> DEFINITIONS

academically credible: Resources and assertions that meet the basic standards of good academic quality. More ...

access (to films): Students must have easy and repeatable access to their films throughout the term; I also have various access requirements. More ...

blind: Partners working separately or, if conversing about something, not leading the other into an interpretation or characterization. More ...

compare: Usually this means finding subtle differences relevant to the class and core values. More ...

compound statements: Avoid compound statements. More ...

content / content rich: Avoid topical descriptions, give me specific content. More ...

deducing values & worldviews: Thinking of how the narrative at the level of story "treats" a character's choices, and thinking of how the narrative presents a character's choices are good starts. More ...

E. A. Countries: Japan, Korea and China. More ...

film title management: The basic citation in all cases except the bibliography follows this pattern: Three Times (Taiwan, 2005). For the complicated bibliographic citation, specific to this course, go here; More ...

film summary: 300-500 words with specific requirements, graded lightly at first then carefully at the ICE stage. More ...

FJS: Final Joint Segment. More ...

ICE: Individual Comparative Essay. More ...

instance: "Instance" is any text, film, passage, scene or other sort of moment that has become the object of analysis and is situated in a very specific time & place. More ...

JES: Joint Essay Set. This is the umbrella term for the entire essay project in its many steps. The name is meant to emphasize the team-based, dialogic nature of the assignment.

meeting details: These details are important, graded carefully and must be content-rich. More ...

NDT: Narrowly Defined Topic. This is the mutual decided topic for the individual essays. More ...

overreach: Conclusions or even speculations that are broader than is warranted. More ...

PCS: Preliminary Comparative Statement. "Preliminary" means "ahead of writing your ICE".

relate: An analytic method that asks you to speculate in one, some or all of these three basic spectrums: presence/absence, degree of modification, acceptance/resistance. More ...

romance: My working definition of "romance" for this class. More ...

story / story's world: We cannot deduce a text's or film's values based solely on narrative events; it is necessary to think about how those events are presented. More ...

term slippage: A messy exploration of an idea, or a sly rhetorical move when done on purpose. More ...

values / worldview: For this class, worldviews and values both contribute to context and help us understand cultural differences. Worldviews are primarily metaphysical; values are similar to social norms. More ...